This Etsy thing is a headache
A. Lorena HaldemanThe other day in my post about social media, I mentioned some changes Etsy is making, and let me tell y'all that craft community is GOING BANANAS over this. Some Makers are leaving Etsy immediately. Some Makers are going to leave Etsy on December 14th, two days before the new changes take effect on the 16th. Some Makers are not leaving Etsy because they can't find anything else that works for them. Some Makers are not leaving Etsy because they aren't phased by the additions in the TOS. Some Makers are writing reasoned approaches on how to interpret the changes (since unsurprisingly Etsy is not being very vocal and helpful with explanations). Some Makers are writing screeds about how there's nothing new in the upcoming TOS changes and how everyone else is just panicking and arm waving.
good lord, y'all
I started on Etsy; I outgrew it pretty quickly for reasons that sixteen years later aren't even really important, and moved over to Shopify, but I kept the store there but empty because I didn't want to risk anyone taking my shop name and filling it with garbage I didn't make but that (if the Internet is any indication) customers would yell at me about. A couple of years ago I found an app for Shopify that will sync your Shopify shop with your Etsy shop. Everything still goes through the back end of Shopify and syncs your inventory, so I started using it, and I get a few sales a month through there.
Etsy has had it's ups and downs for sellers over the years - I'm not going to get into it because I just don't have the time and energy both to research everything to make sure I get my whingings right. Suffice to say that slowly over time the actual Makers have gone from loving to love/hating to barely tolerating Etsy as a necessary evil, and especially over the last year or two Ai peddlers/scammers have really made it difficult to find real things. (Especially if you're trying to find handbuilt pottery templates, my GHOD the absolutely unworkable crap that's out there!!!!)
A few weeks ago Etsy said that they were going to start cracking down on Ai shops. That even if you use Ai to edit your photos, you must have one unedited photo of your actual item with a real live background. Which sounds great BUT because Etsy isn't really into explanations this sort of churned up with water with "well do they mean not cropped? So people are going to see my messy table because cropping is Ai? So I can't fix the lighting? But my phone doesn't photograph blues well, now my photos won't look like what the item I make really looks like if I can't edit the highlights/shadows/whatever." People were losing their minds. "I'm going to leave Etsy if I can't crop my messy table out of my pictures!"
heavy sigh
One day in all my copious free time I'm going to write a post about how exhausting it is to be alive in this time and how we're all supposed to get just as angry about theoretically not being allowed to crop our photos as we're supposed to get about an unjust war in a foreign country.
Etsy has always had rules (although some may argue they're arbitrary about enforcing them) for both buyers and sellers (and affiliates)
- what you can sell
- what you can't sell
- standards you must agree to regarding processing/shipping times, message response times (Meta has this too, and it drives me NUTS because so many friends send me cute dog videos through Insta that don't need replies, but if I don't reply I get dinged by Meta) and so on
- upholding community/communication standards and not using harassment/discrimination
- rules about purchase protection, cases, cancellations, refund, etc
- affiliates/API policies
- buyer policies
But what people are up in arms about right now is the Terms of Use.
One of them is 6D:
D. Etsy AI Tools. Etsy may offer artificial intelligence-powered tools and features as part of our Services (“AI Tools”). You are responsible for reviewing, evaluating, and determining the appropriateness of any AI-generated output before using it and you assume all risk arising from your reliance on AI-generated output. Outputs generated by AI Tools may be inaccurate, incomplete, or unsuitable for your purposes and Etsy makes no representations or warranties about the accuracy, completeness, reliability or suitability of any content, recommendation or other output generated by any AI Tool. Your use of AI Tools and any outputs derived from them remains subject to these Terms and all of Etsy’s policies.
A lot of people are screaming because how can they be telling us about the Ai stuff they're doing when they're also trying to cancel all the Ai shops? Isn't Ai, Ai? Are they trying to cancel everyone else's Ai to use their own?! All I can tell you is there's a huge difference between some Ai spitting out a handbuilt pottery pattern that is physically impossible to put together but wanting $5 for it AND some Ai suggesting you put your soap dishes in the "home decorating" section when you're writing the listing it's going to cost you twenty cents to post.
As near as I can tell from using my own brain and reading what a few other people have written on Facebook and Reddit, 6D is saying that if you use Ai suggestions that Etsy will offer, such as suggesting categories for your products, or suggesting product names/titles, they might suck because Ai is stupid sometimes and so you're on your own if you use them.
6E and 6F also have new verbiage but it's basically saying that you can't reverse engineer Etsy's Ai system or build your own that will do the same thing and load it onto Etsy, interfering with theirs.
I think Section 8 has some new wording as well about third parties, but it seems to be saying basically the same thing as about their Ai; some Third Parties can suck so you're on your own if you use them and Etsy isn't responsible for them. That one makes sense - it's similar to how I can sell you a mug, and I can ship it however you want, but I'm also not in charge of the shipping company so if it takes a day longer to get to you than we thought, I am not responsible for that because I don't own UPS.
There's an image going around highlighting some text, and it does sound scary. I'm going to include it here:
So. The Internet is sharing this image around (I hope they're giving props to the amazing F&SF artist who made it; his handle is on the image and you should go find him from his handle on the image!).
Part of the issue is that people are just now seeing this, when some of it has been in the TOS for a while. Another part of the issue is the phrasing in this Etsy TOU - it's so ... vague.
- Are they talking about using our "content to develop, train, test, and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies" as in, they are going to train Ai to make the stuff we make, so they can sell it, and take us out of the picture?
- Are they saying they're going to train Ai on our stuff so that it knows the difference between real things, and Ai-made things, to help weed out the Ai scam shops?
It took me about an hour digging around in the Etsy TOS to find the text the image above is from, and there's actually... a lot left out. Here's the whole thing (it's from Section 5 "Your Content"):
C. Rights You Grant Etsy. (Here’s the legalese version of the last section). By posting Your Content, you grant Etsy and, as authorized by Etsy in its sole discretion, third parties, a non-exclusive, worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, sub-licensable, perpetual license to use, display, edit, modify, reproduce, distribute, store, and prepare derivative works from Your Content. This allows us to provide the Services and to promote Etsy, your Etsy shop, other shops and listings, or the Services in general, in any formats and through any channels, including across any Etsy Services, our partners, or third-party website or advertising medium. You agree not to assert any moral rights or rights of publicity against us for using Your Content. You also recognize our legitimate interest in using it, in accordance with the scope of this license, to the extent Your Content contains any personal information. This also includes the right for us and our third party partners and vendors to use Your Content to develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies, including to improve the Services and/or help keep them safe, subject to any applicable opt-out rights described in our Privacy Policy.
That sounds like a lot, but it’s necessary for us to keep Etsy going. Consider these examples: if you upload a photo or video of a listing on your Etsy shop, we have permission to display it to buyers, and we can resize or enhance it so it looks good to a buyer using our mobile app; if you post a description in English, we can translate it into French so a buyer in Paris can learn the story behind your item; and if you post a beautiful photo or video of your latest handmade necklace, we can feature it– often along with your shop name and shop picture– on our homepage, in one of our blogs or even on a billboard to help promote your business and Etsy’s.
That second paragraph actually makes it sound pretty benign. Helpful, even. It makes it sound, to me, that they're talking about being able to use our Content in Etsy advertising, which... wouldn't you want to be advertised by Etsy, if you sold there? And that they might use Ai to translate text, or resize a photo on the fly. I... I have surprisingly little issue with that. I supposed if I wanted to jump straight to the Island of Conclusions, I could assume that this is laying the groundwork for Etsy to eventually ... take over the crafting world? With Ai-made mugs? But if Ai can't make a template that makes a functional mug, I doubt it can make an actual functional mug.
Honestly, the more I read about what Etsy is doing, and dig into their ACTUAL Terms of Use, instead of reading panicked posts online, the less I'm worried about what they're putting in the TOS. Or TOU, whatever you want to call it. I'm probably going to keep that app I mentioned up top, that syncs my Shopify store to my Etsy store. And I'm curious about what Etsy will look like in a few months if they really are able to weed out a lot of the Ai scam shops.
Now if you'll excuse me, I've been at this post for about three hours, including research. My back hurts, my leg has fallen asleep from my dog sleeping on my lap for so long, I REALLY have to go get rid of the coffee I drank earlier, and I'm about two hours later getting into the studio today than I wanted to be. But I also wanted to get this out of my head and onto the page.
Do you sell on Etsy? Buy on Etsy? What are your thoughts about this?